I feel Vick is up in the air. I feel he never SHOWED signs of his skills being diminished so he shouldn't of shown SUCH a decline, but then part of me says maybe just a pinch. Bottom line, the only thing keeping him above Vince young is the +5 speed over young, otherwise they'd be the same overall.
Favre should definitely be at LEAST an 85. He IS an elite quarterback, and still can play at high level, barring no injuries. I feel there should be more of an argument of him being underrated, then Vick being Overrated